SEPTEMBER 3, 2012 VOLUME 19 NUMBER 34
I'm thinking about setting up a special needs trust for my son, who has a developmental disability. Will it mean a lot more work for my daughter, who will be handling the estate?
It's a fair question, and one we hear a lot. No one ever asks: "could you please give us the most complicated estate plan possible?" Everyone wants things as simple as they can be.
When you think about providing an inheritance for your child -- or anyone, for that matter -- with a disability, there are some realities you just have to deal with. Those realities almost always lead to the same conclusion: a special needs trust is probably the right answer. There are a number of answers to the "can't we keep it more simple?" question:
- In most cases there's going to be a trust, whether you set it up or not. If you leave money outright to a person suffering from a disability, someone is probably going to have to transfer that inheritance to a trust in order to allow them to continue to receive public benefits. The trust set up after your death will be what's called a "first-person" (or "self-settled") trust, and the rules governing its use will be more restrictive. There will also have to be a "pay-back" provision for state Medicaid benefits when your son dies -- so you will lose control over who receives the money you could have set aside. Even if no trust is set up, there is a high likelihood that your son will (because of his disability) require appointment of a conservator. The cost, loss of family control and interference by the legal system will consume a significant part of the inheritance you leave and frustrate those who are caring for your son. If you prepare a special needs trust now it sidesteps those limitations.
- The trust you set up will not be that complicated to manage. People often overestimate the difficulty of handling a trust. Yes, there are tax returns to file, and summary accounting requirements. Neither is that complicated; neither is anywhere near as expensive as the likely costs of not creating a special needs trust.
- Your daughter can hire experts to handle anything that she finds difficult. There are lawyers, accountants, care managers and even trust administrators who can take care of the heavy lifting for your daughter -- or whomever you name as trustee. The costs can be paid out of the trust itself, so she will not be using her portion of the inheritance you leave, or her own money. Yes, they add an expense -- but they can actually help improve the quality of life for both your daughter the trustee and your son with a disability.
- Your daughter does not have to be the trustee at all. We frequently counsel clients to name someone else -- a bank trust department, a trusted professional, or a different family member -- as trustee. That lets your daughter take the role in your son's life that she's really better suited for: sister. If it is right for your circumstance, you might even consider naming her as "trust protector." That could allow her, for instance, to receive trust accountings and follow up with the trustee, or even to change trustees if the named trustee is unresponsive, or too expensive, or just annoying. Trusts are wonderfully flexible planning devices -- but that does mean you have to do the planning.
- If your son gets better, or no longer requires public benefits, the trust can accommodate those changes. Depending on your son's actual condition and the availability of other resources, you might reasonably hope that he will not need a special needs trust -- or at least might not need one for the rest of his life. The good news: your special needs trust will be flexible enough to allow for the use of his inheritance as if there were no special needs. The bad news: that is only true if you set up the trust terms yourself -- the trust that will be created for him if you do not plan will not have that flexibility.
- Simply disinheriting your son probably is not a good plan. Sometimes clients express concern about the costs and what they perceive as complicated administrative and eligibility issues, and they decide to just leave everything to the children who do not have disabilities. "My daughter will understand that she has to take care of my son," clients tell us. That's fine, and it might well work. But do you feel the same way about your daughter's husband? What about the grandkids and step-grandkids who would inherit "your" money if both your daughter and her husband were to die before your son (the one with the disability)? What about the possibility of creditors' claims against your daughter, or even bankruptcy? Most of our clients quickly recognize that disinheriting the child with a disability is not really a good planning technique.
- But who knows what the public benefits system, the medical care available, or my son's condition might look like twenty years from now? Indeed. That's exactly why the trust is so important.
What does that mean for your planning? If you have a child, spouse or other family member with special needs -- OR if you have a loved one who may have special needs in the future -- your plan should include an appropriate trust. The cost is relatively small, and the benefits are significant. There are really only three downside concerns for special needs planning:
- The cost. But the cost of not doing anything is probably higher -- and the opportunity loss from failure to plan is especially high.
- The nuisance value. Yes, that does mean you need to go see a lawyer. Need a place to start? Look at the membership of the Special Needs Alliance. There's likely someone near you who understands the importance of special needs planning.
- The name. Don't want to tag your loved one as "special needs"? Then don't. Call your trust The John Doe Maximum Opportunity Trust. Or the Panorama 2012 Trust. Or Green Acres Fund. With your lawyer's help, customize the language of your child's trust to speak in your voice, and to identify what you think is important. Take advantage of the flexibility offered by trust planning.